Advances in Hand and Wrist Arthritis Surgery.
Edited By: Magee E. Saewert, MS, PA-C, Thomas Trumble, M.D. Last updated Wednesday, December 30, 2009
|
Figure 1 - Inflammatory arthritis and rheumatoid arthritis manifest themselves in very different forms.
Figure 1a - For additional information regarding hand and wrist arthritis, please see our textbook titled, Principles of Hand Surgery and Therapy
Figure 2 - the hand on the left has not had corrective surgery while the hand on the right has been corrected with surgery including joint replacement.
Figure 3a - In rheumatoid arthritis the MCP joints are most often affected.
Figure 3b - In osteoarthritis the DIP joints are most frequently affected.
Figure 4a - the thumb CMC joint.
Figure 4b - This splint helps to support the thumb and improve the patient?s function with grip and pinching activities.
Figure 5 - a characteristic deformity is the lunar drift of the fingers, which drift toward the small finger side of the hand at the metacarpophalangeal joint.
Figure 6 - The extensor tendons are the ones that are the most vulnerable.
Figure 7 - X-rays demonstrate scalped or punched out lesions of bone destruction adjacent to the joint.
Figure 8 - the carpometacarpal joint of the thumb is the next most commonly involved joint.
Figure 9 - the wrist joint, also referred to as the radiocarpal joint, is the next most commonly involved joint after the the carpometacarpal joint.
Figure 10 - adapted devices will also decrease the stress in the joints and improve the life span of joints afflicted with arthritis.
Figure 11 - a brace that helps to support the wrist in a comfortable position is quite useful.
Figure 12 - Example of gentle stretching exercises known as the ?Six-Pack? exercises.
Figure 13 - shows an application of Parafin C.
Figure 14 - demonstrates significant painful arthritis and joint destruction.
Figure 15 - demonstrates a fusion of a painful DIP joint.
Figure 16 - The PIP joint is extremely important to hand function and flexibility.
Figure 17 - demonstrates destructive changes on x-ray of a painful PIP joint.
Figure 18 - demonstrated the polished black implants being placed at surgery.
Figure 19 - Final implants tapped into position.
Figure 20 - 3. Metacarpophalangeal joint (MCP).
Figure 21 - flexible silicone implants can be used when patients have pain and arthritis.
Figure 22 - demonstrates the replaced MCP joint x-ray.
Figure 23 - shows the polished pyrocarbon implants being placed at surgery.
Figure 24 - shows the painful bone on bone contact at the CMC joint and the large bone spurs referred to as osteophytes.
Figure 25 - shows the placement of the donor cartilage into the joint space.
Figure 26 - demonstrates the joint replacement on x-ray.
Figure 27 - SLAC arthritis
Figure 28 - the ?Spider plate?.
Figure 29 - more extensive arthritis and the entire wrist joint is involved
Figure 30 - wrist replacement surgery.
Figure 31 - wrist replacement surgery.
Figure 32 - The swollen, inflamed material around the tendons causes erosion and eruption of the tendons.
Figure 33 - Tendon reconstruction
Figure 34A - an incision to raise two small flaps on the dorsum or the back of the finger.
Figure 34B - a series of small wires woven between the two bones.
Figure 34C - using small hollow or cannulated screws that can be placed over a guide wire in order to secure and compress the joint surfaces.
Figure 34D - using small hollow or cannulated screws that can be placed over a guide wire in order to secure and compress the joint surfaces.
Figure 35 - joint fusion.
Figure 36 - Special sizes are used to select the correct implant
Figure 37 - Trial implants are used to insure that the measurements are correct.
Figure 38 - Special cutting guides are secured to the bone with pins and a power saw then trims the bone edges.
Figure 38A - the flexible implant in the joint.
Figure 38B - flexible implant with the repaired soft tissues.
Figure 39 - Special reaming devices prepare the canal so that there is an intimate fit for the components avoiding the need for bone cement.
Figure 40 - Another guide is attached to the bone in order to provide for accurate drill placement for the screws that will stabilize the implant to bone.
Figure 41 - a diagram of the plate applied to the wrist.
Figure 42 - a diagram of the plate applied to the wrist.
Figure 43 - the inflamed tissue is highlighted in pink.
Figure 44 - the tendon to the ring finger has ruptured with a loss of material so it can no longer be repaired primarily.
Summary
Overview
Arthritis of the hand and wrist occurs in one of two major forms:
inflammatory arthritis, including conditions such as rheumatoid
arthritis, and the more common form of degenerative arthritis is known
as osteoarthritis. For additional information regarding hand and wrist
arthritis, please see our textbook titled, Principles of Hand Surgery and Therapy. (Figure 1A)Inflammatory
arthritis such as rheumatoid arthritis, have evidence of an autoimmune
malfunction where the body appears to be attacking its own joints.
These conditions often have a hereditary component and can often be
diagnosed with specific blood tests such a rheumatoid factor (RF),
anti-cyclic citrullinated peptide (anti-CCP), antinuclear antibodies
(ANA) and erythrocyte sedimentation rate (ESR). Many types of
inflammatory arthritis also produce systemic illness. Osteoarthritis is
not associated with any clear hereditary pattern although it does seem
to be more pronounced in certain families. There are no corresponding
blood tests to confirm the diagnosis of osteoarthritis and is more of a
rule out diagnosis or exclusion once forms of arthritis have been
eliminated from the diagnosis. As seen in Figure 1 the two
forms of arthritis manifest themselves in very different forms.
Inflammatory arthritis and rheumatoid arthritis creates clear-cut areas
of destruction of the bone with loss of the overall architecture of the
joint. In osteoarthritis, the body attempts to heal the joint
destruction and create bone spurs known as osteophytes that extend pass
the normal confines of the bone. After performing a clinical
examination and obtaining the necessary laboratory tests as well as
x-rays, the physician managing the arthritis can actually diagnosis the
type of arthritis in most cases in order to determine the best type of
medical treatment. Recently, a number of newly designed medications,
such as Etanercept, a medication that inhibits an immune messenger know
as TNF, have been designed to address the immune dysfunction that
occurs in diseases such as rheumatoid arthritis and psoriatic
arthritis. In inflammatory arthritis, the joint can frequently undergo
significant deformity. One characteristic in rheumatoid arthritis is
the ulnar drift or the drift where the fingers all rotate toward the
small finger. (Figure 2) For these patients, special night
splints can be fabricated in order to minimize or slow the progression
of the joint deformity. The splints can be custom fabricated by a hand
therapist using special thermoplastic material that can be molded to
the patient’s hand. The frequency that the joints are affected are
effected provides a pattern that is characteristic of a certain type of
arthritis. (Figure 3A and 3B) In osteoarthritis, the small joint
near the fingertips (distal interphalangeal) (DIP) joints are often
affected first with minimal functional loss although often with
significant cosmetic deformity. The thumb carpal metacarpal (CMC) joint
is frequently affected in osteoarthritis, particularly in women. In
osteoarthritis, braces that help to support the thumb when it is
involved or the wrist can help relieve the patient’s symptoms and avoid
or delay the need for reconstructive joint surgery. (Figure 4A & B)
Often combining these splinting and therapy techniques with
anti-inflammatory medication can provide the patient with substantial
periods of relief and improve their function.
When these techniques do not work and the patient has pain or loss
of function reconstructive surgery with joint replacement surgery or
tendon repair is often required to relieve pain and improve patient
function. The pain occurs when the arthritis has caused destruction of
a joint or tendon. To perform replacement surgery and tendon repair
surgery, it is best performed by a surgical team skilled in hand
surgery with a special emphasis in the reconstruction of arthritis.
Such a team can maximize the benefits and minimize the risks. The
operations can usually be performed under regional or general
anesthesia as an outpatient. In regional anesthesia, the patient’s arm
is made numb with a nerve block and mild sedation is used. Patients are
encouraged to begin motion after surgery, depending on the exact type
of operation that has been performed. In many cases, the hand therapy
is coordinated with therapy in advance.
Characteristics of hand and wrist arthritis
Hand and wrist arthritis is best considered in the two major
classifications that we discussed above: Inflammatory arthritis and the
common wear and tear arthritis referred to osteoarthritis. In
inflammatory arthritis, such as rheumatoid arthritis, the patient so
affected often has marked stiffness in the morning lasting an hour or
more, swelling of the joints of the hands as well as the wrists, and if
untreated medically, may develop permanent damage to the bone and
cartilage and loss of the ability of the supporting structures such as
the tendons to maintain the normal alignment of the joints of the hands
and wrists. As noted in rheumatoid arthritis, a characteristic
deformity is the lunar drift of the fingers, which drift toward the
small finger side of the hand at the metacarpophalangeal joint. (Figure 5)
Inflammation can also erode tendons, which rarely happens in
osteoarthritis. Once the tendons are eroded, the digits can droop,
which is known as an extensor lag. The extensor tendons are the ones
that are the most vulnerable (Figure 6), Nodules can also occur
about the hand and wrist as well as elsewhere in the body. These tend
to occur over joint surfaces on the extensor portion of the hand prime
area is the posterior region of the elbow called the olecranon, but
these are also noted in the small joints in the hand
The treatment of inflammatory arthritis has been revolutionized by
the recent introduction of new medications that are directed against
the immune processes that cause the major damage. Etanercept,
Infliximab, and Adalumumab are three new “biologic” agents that are now
approved to treat rheumatoid arthritis and have had a huge impact in
just a few years. The can effectively suppress inflammation and prevent
damage to the joints. Older drugs such as methotrexate are still widely
used and are often combined with the newer agents with excellent effect.
Types
As discussed above, the two main categories include the arthritis
associated with inflammatory disease such as rheumatoid arthritis and
with the frequently strong genetic history and the more much more
common but less world defined osteoarthritis. Osteoarthritis rarely
affects the soft tissues such as the tendons although joint ligaments
can be damaged as the joints become deformed. In rheumatoid arthritis,
soft tissue damage is one of the hallmarks and frequently there is
tendon rupture causing a loss of hand.
Similar conditions
The key feature is that there are a number of patterns of arthritis
that can occur and can have a different effect on the patient. Some
types of arthritis that are caused by the deposition of crystals in the
joints such as gout and pseudogout. In gout, the crystals are formed
from material called uric acid and in pseudogout; they are formed from
crystals called calcium pyrophosphate. Traumatic arthritis can also
occur in patients who have had prior injury. There is generally a
history corresponding with this, but in some cases the patients do not
recall the history. These conditions and trauma arthritis are isolated
and relate mainly to the joints that were initially injured. It only
causes secondary deformity in the adjacent joints at a very late stage.
A thorough diagnostic workup is important in the initial evaluation of
arthritis to make sure that the correct type of arthritis is identified
so that the treatment is well organized.Incidence and risk factors
Osteoarthritis is much more common than rheumatoid arthritis. Together
the two conditions are the leading causes of disability in the United
States for both men and women. Women tend to develop osteoarthritis at
an earlier age in the upper extremity than do men. In particular, the
thumb is commonly involved. In some studies, nearly 40% of women over
the age of 60 have developed some form of arthritis in the thumb or
elsewhere in the hand and wrist.Diagnosis
Arthritis is diagnosed by the patient’s history, physical
examination, as well has x-rays showing ‘punched out lesions’ and
laboratory studies. Swelling and tenderness around the joints with
limitations of motion is one of the hallmark signs of arthritis.
Instability and deformity of the joint occurs later in the course of
the disease. The following clinical features correlate with certain
types of arthritis.
Rheumatoid arthritis: The ulna deviation of the deformity of the hand at the level of the metacarpophalangeal joint (See Figure 5). Nodules can occur, particularly on the extensor surfaces and it is frequently warm when the swelling occurs.
Laboratory tests: Rheumatoid factor is positive in
approximately 80% of patients and a newer test the anti-cyclic
citrullinated peptide is even more specific for rheumatoid arthritis.
The erythrocyte sedimentation is often elevated as well. This is a
general sign of inflammation that can correlate with infection or
arthritis. It is not a specific test, but helps to monitor the course
of the disease. X-rays demonstrate scalped or punched out lesions of
bone destruction adjacent to the joint. (Figure 7) The joint
surfaces are referred to as the articular surfaces, and therefore the
fact that these lesions occur adjacent to these lesions adjacent to the
joint surface or on the perimeter of the joint surface has resulted in
the term, ‘periarticular erosions.’
Lupus: This is also much more common in women, and is diagnosed
by an elevated antinuclear antibody (ANA). There may be joint deformity
with x-rays demonstrating far less destructive changes than occurs with
rheumatoid arthritis. Redness around the face occurs around the eyes
and cheeks in a hallmark fashion that is referred to a butterfly rash
and occurs in a majority of patients at some point of their condition.
Psoriatic arthritis: In the majority of these patients, the
rheumatoid factor and antinuclear antibodies are negative, but
erythrocyte sedimentation rate can be elevated. The patients
demonstrate joint swelling that that can affect an entire finger or toe
and is referred to as a sausage digit. Psoriatic arthritis can damage
the bone and cartilage just as rheumatoid arthritis. Patients usually
demonstrate a scaly psoriatic rash along the scalp, trunk, or arms or
legs in the course of the disease.
Gout: Men more commonly develop gout than women. It usually
occurs n the third and fourth decades of life. In addition to the
hands, the big toe is commonly affected and titled Podagra for its
presentation. The joints are hot and swollen when the gout is active.
The majority of patients have elevated uric acid levels that are tested
on blood tests and when the joint tapped and fluid is drawn from the
joints, the sharp edge to gouty crystals are frequently seen in the
joint fluid. Gout responds well to medications that diminish
inflammation such as indomethacin or even prednisone. Allopurinol can
be an excellent way to treat the patient on a long-term basis. The
destructive or punched out lesions are present around the joints
similar to rheumatoid arthritis, but when the crystal deposits become
large enough, they form masses called tophi that can also be seen as a
hazy, mass on x-ray.
Osteoarthritis: This condition is the most common and has the
least characteristic signs. Radiographs are often quite classic with
patients with development of changes in bone spurs with new bone
formation outside the normal confines of the skeleton. The laboratory
tests are generally negative. When fluid is dropped from the joint,
there is noted to be an increased level of numbers of white blood
cells, but far less than that occurs the types of inflammatory
arthritis or gouty/crystal and arthritis described above. In
osteoarthritis, the PIP joints are frequently affected. The distal
phalangeal (DIP) joints are frequently affected. (Figure 3B). In addition, the carpometacarpal joint of the thumb is the next most commonly involved joint (Figure 8) followed by the wrist joint also referred to as the radiocarpal joint (Figure 9)
Medications
Although nonsteroidal inflammatory drugs (NSAIDS) like ibuprofen and
naproxen as well as newer drugs rofecoxib and celecoxib can help to
relieve symptoms in the majority of patients with arthritis. Braces
that help to alleviate stress in the joints can be uniformly helpful.
In addition, adapted devices that help to improve the leverage that the
patient can apply to opening jars, cutting food, etc. will also
decrease the stress in the joints and improve the life span of joints
afflicted with arthritis. (Figure 10) When the thumb is involved, a special splint called opponents splint can be extremely helpful. (Figure 4B) When the wrist is involved, a brace that helps to support the wrist in a comfortable position is quite useful. (Figure 11).
Specific Drug Treatment by Diagnosis:
In order of increasing immunosuppressant power, available drugs
include Hydroxychloroquine, Sulfasalazine, Azathioprine, and
Methotrexate. Steroid medication has a rapid effect, but can cause a
significant side effects such as osteoporosis. The disease modifying
Antirheumatic drugs are referred to DMARDs.
Systemic lupus erythematosus: Treatment depends on disease
severity. Steroids are the mainstay with Hydroxychloroquine,
Methotrexate, Azathioprine, and Cyclophosphamide used as needed.
Rheumatoid arthritis: Hydroxychloroquine, Sulfasalazine,
Methotrexate, Leflunomide, Etanercept, Infliximab, Adalumumab are
medications that can be used in this disease.
Scleroderma (CREST Disorder): The acronym CREST stands for:
C – calcinosiscutis
R – raynaud’s syndrome
E – esophageal motility disorders
S – sclerodactyly, thickening of the skin of the fingers
T – telangiectasia
Medical therapy can include calcium channel blocking drugs, nitrogen paste, and infusion of prostaglandin analogs.
Psoriatic Arthritis: For the medical management of psoriatic rheumatoid arthritis, high-dose steroids should be avoided.
Crystalline arthropathies:
Gout
The acute attacks respond well to high-dose non-steroidal
anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDS), Colchicine can be used to prevent
attacks. Oral and injectable steroids can also be effective.
Allopurinol blocks the breakdown pathway of purines and was thought to
be effective in preventing attacks of gout, but more recent evidence
questions the efficacy of the drug.
Chondrocalcinosis (Pseudogout)
Steroid injections into the inflamed joint and NSAIDS can be a very effective treatments.
Exercises
Exercises can help to maintain joint mobility in arthritis. This should
include gentle stretching exercises often after applying heat. Heavy
repetitive exercises that stress the joint should be avoided.
Prolonged, heavy pinching should also be avoided, since there is
approximately 10 pounds of force transferred to the joint at the base
of the thumb for every 1 pound of pinch force at the tip of the thumb.
Example of gentle stretching exercises known as the ‘Six-Pack’
exercises is shown in (Figure 12) Special techniques in hand
therapy can be extremely helpful, especially heat using techniques such
as the application f heat with a warm wax, paraffin C,’ that is applied
to the hand or a dry heat using fluido therapy, using warm air and
ground corn husk. (Figure 13) The use of adaptive equipment,
which decreases the amount of force required to pinch or techniques
with standard and non-steroid inflammatory increases the leverage, can
help to decrease pain and prevent further injury to joints. (Figure 10) A hand therapist can assist in finding appropriate adaptive equipment and teaching additional joint protection techniques.Possible benefits of hand and wrist arthritis surgery
Prior to surgery for the hand and wrist can be extremely helpful
when other modalities such as drug therapy and splints no longer
provide the patients with sufficient pain relief or improvement of
function. When patients have difficulty performing even simply
household tasks despite braces and therapy, surgery can be extremely
helpful.
Reconstructive Hand and Wrist Arthritis Surgery includes one of four types of treatments:
Joint replacement surgery: This surgery corrects the deformed
and arthritic joints to prevent the bone on bone contact that produces
the severe grinding pain. It is particularly important where motion is
a high priority, including the CMC joint at the base of the thumb, the
PIP joint in the middle of the digits, and the MCP joints at the base
of the digits as well as in the wrist.
Joint fusion or arthrodesis or fusion of the joint: Fusion
eliminates the motion in the joint that produces pain by fusing the two
bone surfaces together. Patients obtain relief of pain and stability,
but they lose the joint motion. This is most successful in the small
Dip joints, but can also be used in the wrist for a partial fusion or
complete fusion.
Synovectomy to remove the inflamed joint or tendon lining:
There is strong clinical evidence to suggest that the persistence of
the swelling around tendons or joints referred as synovitis can produce
severe destructive changes if careful medical management cannot
eliminate the synovitis within a six month period of time. The
synovectomy can relieve pain and prevent tendon rupture that causes
severe loss of hand and wrist function.
Tendon repair and reconstructive surgery: In severe cases, once
the arthritis has caused erosion of tendons with rupture, tendon
reconstruction with transfers or grafting can restore function to the
patient’s hand.
Types of surgery recommended
The type of surgery that is recommended is probably best described
by reviewing the joint that is affected in arthritis of the hand and
wrist.
Arthritis of the DIP joint (Figure 14).
Figure 14 demonstrates significant painful arthritis and joint
destruction. Although small joint replacement can be accomplished for
patients with arthritis without deformity, for most patients with
arthritis, a fusion is often recommended (Figure 15). Figure 15 demonstrates a fusion of a painful DIP joint.
PIP joint (Figure 16).
The PIP joint is extremely important to hand function and flexibility. Figure 17
demonstrates destructive changes on x-ray of a painful PIP joint. It is
often referred to as the ‘soul of the hand’ because it is so critical
for finger and hand motion. When painful arthritis occurs with
destruction of bone on bone contact, joint replacement surgery is
considered. (Figure 17, 18). Figure 17 shows an x-ray of the
replacement PIP joint and figure 18 demonstrated the polished black
implants being placed at surgery.
Metacarpophalangeal joint (MCP)
(Figure 20).
Destruction and deformity of the metacarpophalangeal joints often with
‘punched out defects in the bones’ are a hallmarks of rheumatoid
arthritis as shown in figure 20. When deformity and arthritis is
present especially in multiple joints, flexible silicone implants can
be used when patients have pain and arthritis as demonstrated in figure
21. (Figure 21). When patients have significant arthritis but no
deformity, replacements can be used that reconstruct joint surfaces and
allow maximum motion components that can glide on top of one another
(articulate) that more closely resemble the original joint. (Figure 22, 23).
Figure 22 demonstrates the replaced MCP joint x-ray and figure 23 shows
the polished pyrocarbon implants being placed at surgery.
Arthritis of the thumb basal joint (CMC Arthritis) (Figure 24).
Figure 24 shows the painful bone on bone contact at the CMC joint and
the large bone spurs referred to as osteophytes. Depending on the
extent of the arthritis and the instability of the joint, joint
replacements need to be designed to address all the structural problems
that are caused by the arthritis. The key feature is providing the
removal of the bone on bone contact. Donor cartilage restores the space
between the bone surfaces with cartilage that is from the tissue bank
that is carved to the particular patient’s dimensions. (Figure 25, 26).
Figure 25 shows the placement of the donor cartilage into the joint
space and figure 26 demonstrates the joint replacement on x-ray.
Arthritis of the wrist
When the arthritis does not involve all the joint surfaces such as found in the SLAC arthritis, (Figure 27),
a partial wrist fusion can be extremely successful in relieving pain
while still preserving some joint motion. In this fusion, several
arthritic bones are fused together using a small ring-like plate that
has been referred to as the ‘Spider plate’ because of the way the eight
screws branch out like the likes of a spider. (Figure 28).
Surgery is performed with a special technique that uses specialized
instruments to remove the arthritic bone surfaces and fuse them
together while preserving joint surfaces that are normal to preserve
joint motion. (See Movie SLAC Arthritis). When arthritis is more extensive and the entire wrist joint is involved (Figure 29),
the surgeons needs to perform either wrist replacement surgery where
the joint surfaces are removed and are replaced with an artificial
joint (Figure 30, 31), or perform a wrist fusion surgery. Joint
replacement surgery is indicated for patients with many areas of
arthritis in their hands, arms and legs with a lower activity level and
need to preserve as much motion as possible to do their activities of
daily living. Wrist fusion surgery is indicated for patients who are
active with involvement of only a single wrist and sparing the opposite
wrist. Wrist fusion relieves pain and provides stability, but
eliminates wrist motion. This technique is particularly helpful where
an injury has caused the destruction of one wrist joint but the
opposite wrist joint has no evidence of arthritis.
Tenosynovitis of the Hand and Wrist
This commonly occurs on the wrist in patients with rheumatoid
arthritis, particularly on the dorsum or backside of the wrist. The
swollen, inflamed material around the tendons causes erosion and
eruption of the tendons. (Figure 32).
An incision has to be made over the tendons and the inflamed material
thoroughly removed. Studies have clearly shown that removing the
inflamed synovium early (tenosnovectomy) dramatically decreases the
rate of tendon rupture.
Tendon reconstruction
Once the tendons have ruptured, a lag or loss motion has occurred (Figure 6)
reconstruction of the tendons needs to be performed, frequently using
tendon transfers where an intact rupture tendon is sutured to an
adjacent intact tendon or tendon grafts where a motion of one tendon
that is not essential is used to splice into or graft a ruptured
tendon. (Figure 33). Consideration for arthritis surgery for the hand and wrist should be considered in more cases.
Downloads
Who should consider hand and wrist arthritis surgery?
Patients with severe joint pain that interferes with simple daily activities or sleep
• Swelling around tendons despite six months of appropriate drug
treatment to reduce the arthritis should consider a synovectomy.
• Joint replacement or joint fusion surgery
• Tenosynovectomy to prevent tendon rupture
• Patients who have had tendon rupture with loss of function should consider reconstructive tendon surgery.
What happens without surgery?
The outcome depends on how the arthritis has manifested itself.
• Patients with severe joint arthritis can notice loss of function
over time with increasing pain. The rate of symptom change with
arthritis can be highly variable. In some cases, in joint arthritis a
deformity develops over time that requires more extensive
reconstructive surgery if the initial surgery to replace or refuse a
joint is delayed. The particulars depend on the individual case and
should be reviewed with a hand surgeon skilled in the treatment of hand
and wrist arthritis.
• Patients with persistent swelling around the tendons
(tenosynovitis) have a high risk to go on to tendon rupture. Tendon
rupture result in significant loss of function that require much more
extensive reconstructive surgery with a much longer period of
rehabilitation. A simple tenosynovectomy can prevent tendon rupture and
allow patients to return to activities within two to four weeks. Once a
tendon rupture has occurred, much more extensive surgery is required
and the rehabilitation period can take several months.
• Permanent stiffness can develop once tendons have ruptured. If
patients develop stiffness following tendon rupture, their outcome
following reconstructive surgery is much more limited than if the
joints repair supple and flexible. The rehabilitation period takes
several months and usually requires some period of immobilization to
protect the repair of reconstructed tendons. If patients have joint
stiffness prior to the surgery, the stiffness can be much worse during
the period of immobilization after the surgery.
Surgical options
The type of surgery depends on the way the arthritis has manifested itself causing:
• Joint destruction
• Tendon swelling and inflammation
• Tendon rupture
The joint that the arthritis is involved also plays a large role in
what type of reconstruction would best improve the patient’s function.
Another important factor is the patient’s activity level. Younger
patients are more active will provide such severe stress to replace
joints that they will often break or dislocate. Although the
recommendation appears paradoxical, joint fusions are more likely to be
recommended for the younger, active patient who will provide
significant stress on the reconstructive joint.
Effectiveness
Joint replacement surgery can be very effective in restoring comfort
and function to the hand of the well-motivated patient. The greatest
benefits are often the ability to sleep without the need for protective
braces and the ability to perform the usual activities of daily living.
As long as proper hand care is preserved and subsequent injuries are
avoided, the benefit can last for decades.
Joint fusion surgery is extremely durable because the bones are
solidly fused. The difficulty becomes in active patients who have
joints that are involved on either side of the fused joints. The
patients supply added stress to the unfused joints and occasionally
this can exacerbated the development of arthritis in these joints.
Tenosynovectomy surgery can provide long lasting and even permanent
relief. Tenosynovectomy can dramatically reduce the risk of tendon
rupture in rheumatoid arthritis. Tendon reconstruction surgery is often
the only way that patients can regain function after tendon rupture.
This usually provides permanent function for the patient and disease
rarely occurs in the reconstructed tendons.
Urgency
In most cases, surgery for hand and wrist arthritis is not an
emergency. Probably the most urgent case for such surgery occurs in
patients who have increasing symptoms with long standing tenosynovitis
that has not responded to drug therapy. The concern is that these
patients are a risk for tendon rupture and that urgent surgery can
prevent the need for a more extensive surgery to reconstruct ruptured
tendons. In most cases, the surgery is elective and can be scheduled at
the patient’s convenience. Before the surgery is undertaken, the
patient needs to:
1. Be in optimal health
2. Understand the risk to alternative surgery
3. Understand the post operative rehabilitation program
4. Have the appropriate adjustment of medications prior to surgery in
order to prevent increased bleeding or infection that can occur with
some of the more potent arthritis medications.
Risks
The risks of hand and wrist arthritis include, but are not limited to
infection, tendon injury, instability of the joint, loosening or wear
of artificial joints, scar tenderness, pain, stiffness, nerve injury in
the knee for additional surgery. An experienced hand surgery team will
use special techniques to minimize these risks, but cannot totally
eliminate them.Managing risk
Hand infections are extremely rare, even in joint reconstruction
surgery. Patients are given antibiotics prior to surgery as a
prophylactic treatment. Nerve and tendon injury can be treated by
surgical repair. Joint instability or joint dislocation can be treated
by revision surgery. If the patient has questions and concerns about
the course after surgery, the surgeon should be informed as soon as
possible.Technical details
The types of techniques used vary depending on the location f the
problem and the severity of the problem, and the activity level of the
patient. The patient’s anatomy and the duration of the arthritis play
also have an impact in designing the correction procedure that is right
for each patient. The procedures listed below are representative of the
types of treatments that are available for the different locations and
problems, but no mean all inclusive.
Arthritis of the DIP joint (Figure 14)
When the patients have pain and deformity that limits them and impairs
their function, joint fusion surgery is often recommended. Joint
replacement surgery can be performed in patients with low demand and
limited activities, but for most active patients, the DIP joint fusion
is more practical. The technique involves making an incision to raise
two small flaps on the dorsum or the back of the finger. This allows
the bone surfaces to be trimmed (Figure 34A) and brought flush with either a series of small wires woven between the two bones (Figure 34B)or
using small hollow or cannulated screws that can be placed over a guide
wire in order to secure and compress the joint surfaces(Figure 34C&D).
The screws can be left in permanently whereas the small longitudinal
wires (as shown in the figure) are removed six to eight weeks after
surgery in the office. Post operatively, the patients wear a splint for
protection for one or two weeks and then they can usually wear small
splints covering the fingertips to protect them while the fusions heal,
but while still allowing motion in the joints. The fusions usually
become solid in six to eight weeks, but patients can do lighter
activities until that time.
Arthritis of the PIP joint (Figure 16)
Although joint fusion can be performed for this joint (Figure 35)
in most cases, the surgeons try to preserve motion in this very
critical joint. A curving incision is made over the dorsum of the
finger so that the arthritic bone ends can be trimmed and the bone
canals enlarge with the use of small reaming devices (Figure 18).
There are different types of joint replacement available. When the
ligaments and other soft tissues have not been damaged by the
arthritis, a special joint replacement is available with FDA approval
for humanitarian use with articulating implants in special research
hospitals. That means that the implants can actually glide on top of
one another similar to the way normal joint functions. Special sizes
are used to select the correct implant (Figure 36) and trial implants are then used to insure that the measurements are correct (Figure 37).
The final implants are then tapped into position and the joints tested
in a range of motion to confirm that the motion has been restored (Figure 19).
The implants do not require cement, but do require an intimate bone fit
for stability, which requires extremely precise surgery Joint motion is
begun in a protected protocol at five days. On your first visit, the
hand therapist will fabricate 2 thermoplastic splints: a dynamic splint
with rubber bands that allows protected exercise of the new joints, and
the second splint is used at night to protect the new joints while
sleeping. The hand therapist will also instruct the patient in a gentle
protected exercise program The patient should be aware that stitches
remain in place for approximately 2 weeks from the time of surgery, and
that it is normal for the hand to remain swollen for some time. The
therapist will review signs of infection to watch for, and the patient
is advised to contact the physician or therapist immediately if they
are having any increased pain, swelling or other signs of infection.
Arthritis of the metacarpophalangeal joint (MCP) (Figure 20)
most frequently occurs with rheumatoid arthritis, but can occur in
cases of osteoarthritis as well as other types of arthritis less
frequently.
The type of surgery and implant selected depends on the degree of
destruction of ligaments and other soft tissues. When the patients have
a severe ulnar drift deformity, meaning that the fingers angle towards
the small finger side of the hand (Figure 7) is important to use more stable implants that can be inserted into both bone canals of the finger as well as the hand (Figure 38 A&B).
When all four fingers are involved, a transverse incision over the
knuckles or the MCP joints can be performed for surgical exposure. When
only one or two digits are involved, longitudinal incisions can be
used. The tendon is incised longitudinally. Arthritic metacarpal heads
are removed (Figure 38A) and the bone canals are enlarged using special power reaming devices (Figure 38B)
For patients with significant ligament destruction, efforts are made to
suture the ligaments back into position and place the stem shaped
silicone rubber implants that have one stem in each canal in order to
help support the joint and restore alignment (Figure 21)
When the ligaments have been preserved, special articulating implants
can be used that restore more gliding motion as the implants glide upon
one another similar to the way the actual joint performs (Figure 20-23).
Arthritis of the basal joint of the thumb
Arthritis in this joint severely disables patient function (Figure 24).
A key factor is whether only the single bone serves between the thumb
metacarpal and the small square bone called the trapezium are affected
or whether the bone surfaces on either side of the trapezium are
affected with destructive arthritis. When the arthritis only involves
the CMC joints, the single (the CMC joint) efforts are made to spare
the other joint and only a portion of the square trapezium bone is
removed in order to insert a bone spacer (Figure 26).
A variety of different materials are available including silicone
rubber implants and in many cases are performed at the University of
Washington Medical Center, a special allograft cartilage can be
designed specifically to the patient’s specifications and inserted. (Figure 25)
demonstrates the partially carved specimen being with the excess
portion being used as a handle to measure the size of placement to
restore the normal height between the two bones as demonstrated on the
x-ray. The cartilage is radial loose and does not show on the x-ray,
but does restore the normal height between the two bones and prevent
the bone on bone contact that causes pain.
Arthritis involving only a portion of the wrist joint
(SLAC) arthritis, which stands for Scapholunate Advance Collapse
Arthritis.
In this pattern of arthritis, the most severe pain
is on the radial or thumb side of the wrist as arthritic changes occur
between the scaphoid and the radius (Figure 27).
For this type of arthritis, the most common procedure recommended is
the partial fusion of the four bones on the ulnar side of the wrist and
the removal of the painful contact between the scaphoid and radius by
removing the scaphoid bone. As demonstrated by the video below, a
straight incision is made over the back of the wrist, also known as the
dorsum. The tendon to the thumb (the extensor pollicis longus) (EPL) is
released from this compartment and retracted to one side of the wrist.
The scaphoid bone is cut in half and then removed, first removing the
proximal half close to the wrist using small levers or osteotomes as
demonstrated in the video, and then the distal or the portion closest
to the fingertips is removed with a special curved scalpel blade. A
small saw or osteotomes can be used to remove a window bone from the
radius so that bone graft can be used. Bone graft from the patient’s
own bone provides the best quality materials to stimulate bone fusion.
The defect in the radius where the bone graft has been harvested can be
filled with a bone substitute. High-speed burrs remove the bone from
the surfaces where the fusion is desired striping away all the
cartilage remnants enhances the fusion. Any cartilage remnants in the
arthritic area inhibit the bone fusion. Guide wires are then used to
stabilize and correct the deformity and additional wires are used to
hold the position. The fore bones are fixed together, and this can be
done in a variety of methods, but one way that is very stable and
minimizes the amount of time that the patient needs to spend in a cast
is a small circular plate referred to as a spider plate. This is placed
into a conical defect prepared with a special reamer and then small
screws are used to stabilize the plate since eight screws span out from
the center of the plate, they resemble the legs of a spider, and hence
the name. The capsule and soft tissues are then repaired and a drain is
frequently used that is brought out through the skin to prevent the
formation of hematoma and clots beneath the skin. The patient or the
family can then remove the drain the following day at home using the
instructions that are provided at the time of the discharge from the
surgery. The special ring like plate then fuses the four bones together
(Figure 28).
Arthritis involves the entire wrist joint (Figure 29)
When the arthritis involves the main joint, the two main choices are
joint replacement and joint fusion. Joint fusion provides a stable
wrist, but no motion is stronger than a joint replacement. Joint
replacement preserves motion, but of course the cost is decrease in
overall motion and a higher chance of higher complication such as
dislocation of the implants or loosen. For replacement surgery, a
longitudinal incision is made over the dorsum or back of the wrist.
Once the tendons are protected and retracted, a flap of the joint
capsule is elevated off the radius for use in reconstruction of the
wrist once the final implant has been placed. Special cutting guides
are secured to the bone with pins and a power saw then trims the bone
edges to provide the correct fit for the joint replacement (Figure 38).
Special reaming devices prepare the canal so that there is an intimate
fit for the components avoiding the need for bone cement (Figure 39).
Another guide is attached to the bone in order to provide for accurate
drill placement for the screws that will stabilize the implant to bone (Figure 40). Trial implants are used to insure that the correct fit will be obtained with the final implants (Figure 30). When the soft tissue tension has been balanced, the final insertion components are inserted.
Total wrist fusion for a patient with arthritis of the wrist joint.
Using a similar exposure of the entire wrist and the distal portion of
the form is exposed so that the bone surface can be denuded a special
plate is applied that helps to lock together the radius, the carpus,
and the metacarpal to the middle finger using small cortical screws. (Figure 41 & 42)
This is designed to fit intimately with the bone and minimize the
irritation of the soft tissues of the tendons and skin gliding over the
plate. A protective splint is used after surgery for approximately six
weeks and then exercise can begin with a removable brace. This
technique eliminates all wrist flexion extension but preserves the
rotation of the forearm.
Persistent synovitis of the hand and wrist
This most often occurs in rheumatoid arthritis with bulging symposium along the course of the wrist (Figure 43).
Once the inflamed tissue has been removed by incising the layer around
the tendons called the reticulum, a portion of the reticulum is then
placed beneath the tendons and a portion is left on top of the tendons
to both protect and prevent synovitis from invading the tendons again
and to prevent the tendons from shifting during wrist motion
particularly during wrist extension. Often times, the end of the ulna
has become destroyed from the arthritis and creates sharp surfaces that
can abrade or cut into the tendons. If that is the case, this is then
trimmed and removed and a layer of soft tissue is wrapped around it .
Repair and reconstruction of ruptured tendons
There are many different patterns of tendon ruptures that can occur,
and the surgeon needs to design the correct reconstruction for each
pattern. In some cases, this can be performed by rotating the ruptured
tendon into a nearby intact tendon (Figure 44).
In this figure, the tendon to the ring finger has ruptured with a loss
of material so it can no longer be repaired primarily. It has been
attached to the adjacent middle finger so that the two will act
together.
In other cases, a tendon needs to be removed from an area where a
tendon can be spared and rotated and attached to support a tendon that
has ruptured. Also shown in the figure is the transfer of the tendon to
the index finger referred to as the extensor indicis proprius (EIP) to
support the small finger. The small finger tendon was too severe in
angle to attach it to the middle finger and a more direct routing can
be performed with an end-to-end repair by transferring the EIP to the
small finger extensor tendon also known as the extensor digiti quinti
(EDQ). After the tendon reconstruction of surgery, dynamic splints have
to be used with special rubber band traction to help maintain the
alignment of the digits and allow protected joint motion without
causing the tendons to rupture. This protective splinting needs to be
maintained for approximately six weeks after the surgery.
Anesthetic
Because of the length of the procedure is generally over an hour for
the reconstruction, the patients can either have a brachial plexus
block with light sedation or general anesthetic can be used. The
patient might want to wish to discuss their preferences with the
anesthesiologist before surgery.
Length of hand and wrist arthritis surgery
The length of procedures can vary substantially depending on the nature
of the procedure. Smaller procedures only involving a single finger
digit may only take 30 minutes whereas larger procedures requiring
multiple digits or involving reconstruction of the wrist with or
without tendon reconstruction may take two hours. The total time for
the anesthetic, preparation, surgery, and bandaging can take two to
three hours. To allow time for check in and recovery, the patient
should plan for at least half a day for their surgery.Pain and pain management
Like many types of surgery for arthritis where segments of the bone are removed and/or replaced or tendons are repaired and reconstructed, the patients will have pain that needs to be managed by strong medications initially and then mild medications for long-term relief. Pain management is a key Component to successful recovery. The patients frequently receive a long acting pain medicine such as Oxycotin or MS Cotin prior to surgery as well as an anti-inflammatory medication to enhance the effect of the narcotics. This is given to the patients by the staff in the recovery room. After the surgery, the patients receive a strong medication such as morphine or fentyl, as well as a strong intravenous anti- inflammatory medication that has a significant affect on pain from bone and joint surgery called ketorolac. pain medications are frequently necessary three to four weeks after the surgery.Use of medications
Patients frequently use pain medication on a regular basis for one week
after the surgery and then intermittently for an additional two weeks
but this varies widely based on each patient’s chemistry and the type
of procedure.Effectiveness of medications
Pain medications can be very powerful and effective. The use lies in
balancing their pain relieving affect and their less desirable effects
for nausea, constipation, dizziness, etc. Good pain control is an
important part of post-operative management. A key factor is the
combination of long acting medications prior to the surgery and then
the use of local anesthetics during the operation to decrease the
patient’s need for narcotics. The more narcotics that are needed, the
more side effects that can occur.Important side effects
Pain medications can cause drowsiness, slowness in breathing, and
difficulty in emptying the bladder, nausea, vomiting, and allergic
reactions. Patients who take substantial narcotic medications
frequently might find the usual dose of pain medication to be less
effective. For some patients balancing the benefit and side effects of
pain medication is challenging. Patients should be notify their surgeon
if they have previous difficulty with pain medication or pain control.
It is very difficult to select the correct of type of medication and
often times a trial period of one medication is necessary is necessary
before switching to a separate medication. The best predictors of
success of medications is the success of the given medication with a
previous operation.Hospital stay
The patient is usually monitored for an hour in the recovery area.
Instructions for office appointments, post-operative instructions, and
pain medications are provided. The post-operative appointments are
coordinated with post-operative therapy. A family member or a friend
escorts the patients out of the surgery center. Dressings and plastic
splints are usually maintained until the patient sees the physician or
hand therapist. The drain, if necessary, is usually removed the
following day and instructions are provided for drain removal.Recovery and rehabilitation in the hospital
After most procedures for hand and wrist arthritis, splints are
necessary for seven to ten days to hold the position of the
reconstructed tendons or joints and allow for the initial phase of
healing. Protection of the repaired tissues is usually required for an
additional month or for a total of six weeks from the surgery.
Additional splints or casts are applied in the office when the patient
returns for a follow-up appointment to have the sutures removed two
weeks after the surgery. Therapy needs to be carefully designed for
each type of procedure in order to prevent stiffness and enhance motion
while still protecting the repaired joint or tendons.Summary of hand and wrist arthritis surgery for hand and wrist arthritis
Surgery for hand and wrist arthritis helps to restore function and in
many cases can help prevent additional damage to structures,
particularly when tenosynovitis occurs. In the hands of an experienced
surgeon, reconstruction for hand and wrist arthritis can be a most
effective method for restoring comfort and function for patients in
pain with damaged joint surfaces or inflamed or disrupted tendons in a
healthy and motivated patient. Pre-planning and persistent
rehabilitation efforts will help assure the best possible result for
the patient.References
Trumble TE: Principles of Hand Surgery and Therapy. Published 2000 by W.B. Saunders, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, Chapter 23, Arthritis, p. 401-35.
Trumble TE, Rafijah G, Allan CH, North E, McCallister WV, Gilbert M: Thumb
trapeziometacarpal joint arthritis: partial trapeziectomy with Ligament
Reconstruction and interposition Costochondral Allograft. J Hand Surg [Am]. 2000 Jan;25(1):61-76.
Surgery for Hand and Wrist Arthritis at the University of Washington, Department of Orthopaedics and Sports Medicine, Seattle, Washington
If you are interested in making an appointment to discuss this procedure in Seattle, you can request an appointment using our online referrals website. To request a referral online, please click here. You can also call 206-598-BONE (2663) to make an appointment. Our clinical center is located in Seattle Washington, USA